Gel vs Liquid vs Pencil Eyeliners

Out of the different types of eyeliners, my favourite formula would be the liquid eyeliner because it has the longest staying power for me. Here are some looks I did with gel, liquid and pencil liners.

Gel ... I'm using M.A.C's blacktrack. This does smudge on me though. It's a softer look than the liquid liner and you get great precision with a brush.

Liquid ... I use the Physicians Formula Eye Booster in Black. This gives me the longest staying power but a more "rigid" line.

Pencil ... I use L'Oreal Extra-Intense Liquid Pencil in Charcoal. It's definitely the fastest to apply and you can smudge it for a smokey look, but staying power and intensity is not as good as the liquid liner.