L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Butterfly Mascara

I'm a big fan of drugstore mascaras because it doesn't hurt when you throw them away frequently. My current favourite is the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Butterfly Mascara in Blackest Black, the waterproof version. What I look for in a mascara:

- Smudge proof

- Keep my lashes curled

- Define and add volume to my lashes

I've tried the regular, non-waterproof version and found that it doesn't hold the curl of my lashes as well as the waterproof. It's harder to remove, but since I don't wear mascara on a daily basis so I'm ok with that. 

There's a difference! You can see my lashes! I would repurchase.